Home About Us Menu Order Online Events News Contact Us
Menu

APPETIZERS

"Call for menu pricing and consultation"

CRAB STUFFED MUSHROOMS (5)

BAKED CRAB DIP - A House Favorite! (served in a bread bowl with toasted bread wedges.)

PRINCE EDWARD ISLAND MUSSELS (one lb. served with grilled bread and choice of Saffron broth with bacon, leeks, & garlic, or Pomodoro sauce. Ask to make it spicy!)

FRESH MOZZARELLA COCKTAIL (with basil, extra virgin olive oil, smoked sea salt, tomato, & grilled bread)

BEER STEAMED SHRIMP (1/2 pound)

CLASSIC POTATO SKINS (with bacon and cheddar cheese)

HAND BREADED SMOKED CHEESE STICKS (5) (smoked provolone hand breaded with side of Pomodoro sauce.)

BEER-BATTER ONION RINGS BASKET

SOUPS

All Homemade Soups
 

French Onion (In a bread bowl)

 

Baked Chili & Cheddar (In a bread bowl)

Maryland Crab

 

Soup Du Jour

 

SIDES & FAVORITES

 

French Fries Basket

 

Add shredded cheddar

 

Fish 'N Chips: fried Haddock & french fries

 
(Ask to have your Haddock beer battered!)

Loaded Fries: chili, cheddar cheese, jalapeno

 

Nachos Grande:chili, tomato, onion, jalapeño, & cheddar cheese

Chicken Tenders with Fries

 

Cheese Quesadillas

 

Add Chicken

 

Add Steak

 
+top+

SALADS - Entrée Style Bowl

Garden Blend

 
Mixed greens, tomato, cucumber, carrots, onions  

Add grilled chicken

 

Add grilled steak or shrimp

 

Add grilled Portobello mushroom:

 

Add your choice of cheese for

 

Grilled Caesar

 
Grilled head of Romaine, homemade croutons, parmesan cheese.  

Add grilled chicken

 

Add grilled steak or shrimp

 

Buffalo Chicken Salad

 

Crisp mixed greens topped with crispy chicken tenders tossed in hot sauce, cheddar cheese, tomato, onion, carrots, and cu-cumber. Served with your choice of dressing on the side.

Cranberry Pecan Chicken Salad

 

Crisp mixed greens topped with sundried cranberries, pecans, bleu cheese crumbles, sliced grilled chicken breast, tomato, onion, carrots, and cucumber. Served with your choice of dressing on the side.

Pittsburgh Steak Salad

 

Just like they do it in da 'Burgh! Sliced Lon-don Broil, hand cut French fries, bleu cheese crumbles, tomato, onion, car-rots, and cucumber atop a bed of mixed greens. Served with your choice of dressing on the side.

Blackened Salmon or Scallops Salad

 

Crisp mixed greens topped with your choice of a Blackened Salmon or Blackened Sea Scallops, tomato, onion, carrots and cucumber. Served with your choice of dressing on the side. Add bleu cheese crumbles for $1.00!

Grilled Trio Salad (Steak, Chicken, Shrimp)

 

Crisp mixed greens topped with flank steak, grilled chicken, shrimp, mozzarella cheese, tomato, onion, carrots and cucumber. Served with your choice of dressing on the side.

+top+

WRAPS

Soft Whole Wheat Tortilla Wrap: Cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato, homemade chips and pickles

Grilled Chicken (Honey mustard dressing)

 

Chicken Caesar (Caesar dressing & parmesan cheese)

 

Buffalo Chicken (Bleu cheese crumbles & hot sauce)

 

Flank Steak (A-1 steak sauce)

 

Cheese Steak (Mayo dressing)

 

Pulled Pork (French fries, coleslaw, BBQ sauce)

 

Eggplant Parmesan (Arugula, tomato, mozzarella, Pomodoro sauce)

 

SPECIALTY BURGER

8oz. Handcrafted Premium Ground Beef. Served with pickle & chips.

 

The Big Burger or Bird

(Cheese, bacon, lettuce, tomato, onion, & mayo)

 

The Black and Bleu Burger

(Cajun blackened, bleu cheese crumbles, jalapenos, hot sauce, lettuce and tomato)

BBQ Smoker Burger

(Applewood smoked bacon, BBQ sauce, pulled pork & cheddar cheese)

Beach Burger –A House Favorite!

(Topped with a homemade crab cake, provolone cheese, lettuce & tomato)

The Old Mill Burger

(Topped with provolone cheese, sauteed mushrooms and onions)

SUBS:

Foot Long Italian Baguette. Served with pickles & homemade chips.

Pulled Pork Boat (A boatload of smoked BBQ pulled pork and cheddar cheese atop an ocean of fries)

Steak Deluxe (Peppers, onions, mushrooms, sauce, mozzarella cheese)

Swiss Flank Steak (Grilled flank steak, mushrooms, Swiss cheese cheese, A1)

Chicken Parmigiana (Chicken breast, marinara, mozzarella)

Chicken Cordon Bleu (Fried chicken breast wrapped in baked ham & Swiss cheese)

The Roethlisberger (8oz grilled burger, sausage patty, scrambled egg, fried onions, cheddar, provolone, side of lettuce & tomato)

Polish Kielbasa -A Pittsburgh staple!
(Polish sausage with fried onion, mayo, & Swiss cheese)

SPECIALTY SANDWICHES

Served with pickle & chips.

The BBQ Chicken Porker

(BBQ chicken breast topped with pulled pork, bacon, and cheddar cheese)

Grilled Portobello

(Portobello mushroom cap, topped with provolone, arugu1a, tomato, fresh roasted garlic mayo)

Clubhouse Club

(Ham, turkey, bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayo. Stacked tall and served with fries)

Fresh Fried or Broiled Haddock

(8oz. Haddock fillet served with lettuce, tomato, and side of fries)

Broiled Crab Cake

(Maryland style crab cake served on a Kaiser roll with lettuce, tomato, and a side of fries)

Pastrami Sandwich

(Topped with Swiss cheese, fried onions, arugula and mustard)

Lemon Pepper Salmon BLT

(Topped with bacon, arugula, tomato, & mayo on whole wheat bread)


SCOZZARO'S
ORIGINAL PITTSBURGH SANDWICH

Sliced whole wheat bread filled with french fries, coleslaw, sliced tomato, melted provolone and your choice of meat:
Ham, Turkey, Pastrami, or Polish Kielbasa


+top+

DINNER ENTREES

HAND-CUT STEAKS AND RIBS

Twin Bacon Wrapped Bistro Filets (6oz each finished with au jus & served over mashed potatoes and choice of side)

Choice New York Strip (12oz cut prepared to your liking & served with two sides)

 

Salted Carmel Pork Mignon Finished with a demi-glace, apple cider reduction. Served over sweet potato mash & choice of side. Served medium, unless otherwise specified

Char-Grilled Ribs: (Slow-cooked pork ribs finished with your choice of sauce – see Wing Flavor section. Served with your choice of two sides.)

Half Rack

 

Full Rack

 

Black & Bleu Tips 10oz blackened beef tips with bleu cheese crumbles in au jus.

 
+top+

SEAFOOD SELECTIONS

Served with choice of potato and chef vegetable

Broiled or Fried Haddock (8oz)

 

Pan Seared or Blackened Salmon (8oz)

 

Fresh Scallops (Pan seared, broiled, blackened, or fried)

 

Twin 4oz Broiled Lump Crab Cakes (*Gluten Free Crab Cakes Available Upon Request*)

 

Broiled or Fried Seafood Platter (Shrimp, scallops, cod, crab cake)

 

Sides: Herb roasted potatoes, sweet potatoes, mashed potatoes, sweet potato mash, shoestring fries, sweet potato fries, onion rings, vegetable du jour, coleslaw, apple sauce, garden blend salad, caesar salad

+top+

HOUSE SPECIALTIES

Served with House salad & garlic sticks

Smokehouse Mac & Cheese (Blend of four cheeses, Polish kielbasa, tomato, bacon, & topped with toasted bread crumbs)

Baked Cheese-Stuffed Shells

 

Chicken Parmigiana (Served over penne pomodoro)

 

Eggplant Parmigiana (Served over penne pomodoro)

 

Penne Alfredo

 

Add Chicken

 

Add Shrimp

 

Penne Vegetable Pomodoro

 

Penne with Shrimp and Scallop in Blush Tomato

 
+top+

AWARD WINNING WINGS

Our Jumbo Size Wings, Your Way!

Breaded or Naked

Hot

BBQ

Kaitlyn's Secret Sauce
(If you like sweet, spicy, & Asian!)

Mild

Whiskey BBQ

Italian Parmigiana

Sweet Chili

Honey BBQ

Dry Old Bay

Habanero (Tier 1, 2, or 3!)

Hot Honey BBQ

Dry Jamaican Jerk

Hot BBQ

Sweet & Sour

Dry Pepper Parmigiana

Hot Garlic

Honey Bourbon

Dry Parmesan Ranch

Hot Honey

Candy Garlic

Dry Montreal

Kickin' Ranch Butter Garlic Dry Lemon Pepper
Chipotle Ranch Teriyaki Dry Ragin' Cajun
Habanero Ranch Ginger Honey Garlic Dry 7 Pepper
 

10 Wings

20 Wings

100 Wings

 

 

 

6 Wings Served over French Fries with Choice of Sauce ….
Celery & Bleu Cheese or Ranch ...Extra Sauces
+top+

FLAT BREAD PIZZA SPECIALTIES

Personal sized cheese

 

House Favorites

 

       
Your choice of any
additional toppings
Margherita
BBQ Pulled Pork
Buffalo Chicken
 
+top+

Children's Menu

Under the age of 10 Soft beverages or milk included

Add Cheeseburger Sliders with fries
Grilled Cheese with Chips
Add Fried Mac and Cheese
Pasta with Tomato Sauce
Cheese Pita Pizza
Chicken Tenders with French Fries

+top+

CATERING MENU

Please allow 24-48 hour notice for proper consultation, food preparation, service staff setup & delivery.
Prices subject to change based on market pricing. Please call for pricing

Salads

Half Tray

Medium Tray

Full Tray

Garden/Caesar

"Call for menu pricing and consultation"

Pasta/Cole Slaw/Potato

Greek or Grilled Chicken Breast

Grilled Ribeye or Shrimp

Fresh Cubed Fruit

Meat Dishes

London Broil Marsala, Beef Tips Marsala or Burgundy, Baked Glazed Ham, Roasted Pork Loin with Pineapple Island BBQ or Sweet 'n Sour Sauce, Apple Jack Pork Loin, Italian, Swedish, BBQ, or Sweet 'n Sour Meatballs, Roasted Italian Sausage with Peppers, St. Louis BBQ Riblettes, Grilled Pepper Flank Steak, Pulled BBQ Pork

 

 

Half Tray

Medium Tray

Full Tray

"Call for menu pricing and consultation"

Chicken Dishes

Chicken Marsala; Lemon Pepper Chicken, Chicken Teriyaki, Chicken Parthigiana, Chicken Cacciatore, Chicken Cordon Bleu, Chicken Kiev, Stuffed Chicken Breast, Grilled Chicken Breast with Veggies,

Chicken with Shrimp Florentine, Chicken with Shrimp L'orange

Half Tray

Medium Tray

Full Tray

"Call for menu pricing and consultation"

BBQ Chicken & Rib Combo

 

Chicken Pieces Served Bone-In: Seasoned Baked or BBQ

30 pc

50 pc

 

"Call for menu pricing and consultation"

Seafood Entrée

Fresh Catch, Broiled Salmon, Haddock, Seafood Steamer, and *Crab Cakes available at market price.•

 

Half Tray

Medium Tray

Full Tray

"Call for menu pricing and consultation"

Baked Pasta Ricotta

Half Tray

Medium Tray

Full Tray

Pene, Rigatoni, Rotelli, Stuffed Shells, Cheese Tortellini

"Call for menu pricing and consultation"

Special Pasta Dishes

Penne Primavera (Vegetarian), Meat Lasagna, Baked Pasta Alfredo, Baked Pasta Ricotta with Meatballs/Sausage, Baked Pene Chicken Florentine, Baked Pene Chicken Broccoli, Pasta Shrimp or Crab Alfredo, Pene with Seafood Marinara.

 

Half Tray

Medium Tray

Full Tray

"Call for menu pricing and consultation"

+top+

SIDE DISHES

 

Half Tray

Medium Tray

Full Tray

Stir Fry: Beef, Chicken, Shrimp, Cajun with Rice.

"Call for menu pricing and consultation"

Rice or Orzo with Vegetables

Potatoes: Roasted Redskins, Mashed/Garlic Mashed

Au Gratin, Bacon Cheddar Mashed

Fresh Vegetables: Garden Blend

Corn O'Brien, Broccoli with Cheese Sauce, Green Bean Almandine, Glazed Baby Carrots

Baked Macaroni with cheese, bacon & tomato

Regular Baked Potato

Gourmet Stuffed Baked Potato

Chicken Wings

Hot, Medium, Mild, BBQ, Garlic, Old Bay, Lemon Pepper, Parmesan Ranch, Jerk, Cajun, Honey Mustard, Sweet 'n Sour


 


"Call for menu pricing and consultation"

100 Pieces for only

Celery Sticks and Bleu Cheese

6" Hoagie Rolls or 4" Kaisers

Ham, Turkey, Roast Beef, Chicken Salad, Tuna Salad, Ham or Turkey Club

12 Pieces for

24 Pieces

Assorted Dinner Roll Sandwich Trays

30 Pieces

60 Pieces

Fresh Baked Breads

Garlic Rolls

Garlic Sticks

Dinner Rolls

French Baguettes

Tomato/Cheese Bruschetta

Stromboli Loaf

Assorted Tortilla Wraps

Garden Veggie

BLT with Cheese

Tuna Salad

Turkey with Cheese

Grilled Chicken Caesar

Bacon Turkey Club & Ham Turkey Club

Grilled Ribeye

18" Party Platter (Serves 30)

Sliced Stromboli

Asst. Fresh Vegetables Crudites

Cubed Meats & Cheeses

Peel & Eat Old Bay Shrimp (large)

Desserts

Large Gourmet Cookies, Mini Fudge Brownies, Fresh Fruit Cups, Fruit cobbler Cups

Half Sheet Cake (12 pc)

OR Full Sheet Cake (32 pc) Chocolate, Vanilla, or Blueberry

*Assorted Gourmet Dessert Tray's Customized and Priced Upon Request*

(48 Hour Notice) Cream Puffs, Black Bottom Cupcakes, Assorted Mini Muffins, Gourmet Dessert Bars, Cakes & Cheesecake

+top+

Complete Plastic Ware

10" Plate, Fork, Knife, Napkin, & Cup

 

Serving Spoon/Fork

 

Chaffing Stand Rentals

 

DELIVERY SERVICE AVAILABLE: BASED ON LOCATION.

Frozen Cocktails

Specials

Strawberry Daquiri
Pina Colada
Margarita
Mudslide
Lava Flow
Melon Margarita
Blue Margarita
Strawberry Mudslide
Bushwacker
Toasted Almond
Strawbeny Paradise

Bud Light/Miller Light Drafts All day everyday.


+top+

COCKTAIL

Scozzaro's Signature Fishbowl Drink Menu and Daily Fishbowl Drink Special

SCOZZARO'S
WINES

House Wines by Canyon Road, Modesto, California.

WHITES

"Call for menu pricing and consultation"

Chardonnay, Pinot Grigio, White Zinfandel

REDS

Cabernet & Merlot

+top+

Bottled Beer List

Coors Light
Miller Lite
Bud Light
Budweiser
Bud Select 55
Bud Light Lime
Michelob Ultra
Natural Lite
Yuengling Lager
Yuengling Lager Light
Corona
N/A Odouls
Corona Lite

Rolling Rock
Sam Adams Boston Lager
MGD
Smirnoff Ice
Blue Moon Belgium
Stella Artois
Troegs Hopback
Guinness Stout
Abita Purple Haze
Harpoon IPA
Victory HopDevil

 

Food Styles

American (Traditional)
Buffets
Burgers
Diners
Italian
Pizza
Sandwiches
Seafood

Services

Takes Reservations
Walk-Ins Welcome
Good For Groups
Good For Kids
Take Out
Catering
Waiter Service
Outdoor Seating

Contact Us

4797 York Road
New Oxford, PA 17350

Tel: 717-624-8987

 
Site by 411eat.com